Focus Energy efficiency

• 20.11.2026

Natural vs. Fluorinated Refrigerants: A Comparison Beyond GWP

Natural and fluorinated refrigerants often show comparable TEWIs: efficiency, electricity mix and environmental impacts become decisive when choosing the refrigerant.

Refrigerant selection is becoming increasingly complex. GWP, energy efficiency, safety, and overall environmental impact must be weighed together, especially as the HVAC/R industry accelerates the transition to climate-friendly fluids.

A recent German study compared 223 refrigeration machines , including 177 chillers and 46 condensing units used in commercial and industrial refrigeration and air conditioning. For 196 of the machines, it was possible to calculate the TEWI, the indicator that combines direct emissions related to the refrigerant with indirect emissions associated with the energy consumed during operation.

The result suggests avoiding overly simple conclusions: natural refrigerants do not automatically have a lower TEWI than fluorinated alternatives . In many configurations, the differences are small, and the system's electricity consumption remains the main contributor to the overall climate impact.

 

The TEWI shows how much the efficiency of the entire system weighs

The comparison highlights a key aspect for refrigeration designers and operators: evaluating the fluid's GWP alone does not fully describe a system's environmental performance.

The TEWI – Total Equivalent Warming Impact takes into account both direct refrigerant emissions and indirect emissions generated by the electricity consumed by the machine over its operating life.

In water-cooled chillers up to 500 kW, the study did not identify a clearly identifiable influence of the refrigerant family on TEWI. Some ammonia-powered units demonstrated high efficiencies, while some propane-powered applications showed room for improvement.

This means that sustainability does not depend exclusively on the fluid, but also on:

  • efficiency of components;
  • refrigeration cycle architecture;
  • operating conditions;
  • system regulation;
  • losses during useful life;
  • total electricity consumption.

The choice should therefore concern the refrigerant and the system as a single project , avoiding automatically attributing better performance to a technology solely on the basis of the type of fluid.

 

The environmental impact does not end with climate change

However, the TEWI also has a limitation: it primarily evaluates the effect on the climate and does not necessarily include all other possible environmental impacts.

It is precisely here that the study identifies an advantage of natural refrigerants. Some fluorinated refrigerants can degrade in the atmosphere, generating trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) , a highly persistent substance associated with the PFAS debate, while other degradation pathways can produce HFC-23, which has a high climate-altering potential.

Natural refrigerants do not generate these compounds. Therefore, considering a broader environmental scope than just TEWI, their use in the types of equipment analyzed demonstrates an advantage.

The comparison thus shows why climate impact and environmental impact are not necessarily synonymous . A system can be competitive in terms of TEWI and at the same time present other critical issues related to the persistence or degradation products of the refrigerant.

 

The electrical mix can change the outcome over time

Finally, there is an element destined to become increasingly important: the progressive decarbonization of electricity production.

Today, a significant portion of the TEWI of many refrigeration systems comes from indirect emissions associated with the electricity consumed. But as the electricity mix becomes progressively more renewable and less emitting, the weight of indirect emissions decreases and, proportionately, that of direct emissions related to the refrigerant increases .

Comparing refrigerants is therefore not static. A solution evaluated today in a given electrical system may have a different balance over its useful life.

For designers and builders, this reinforces the need to think long-term, simultaneously considering energy efficiency, losses, GWP, system lifespan, and possible evolution of the electricity mix.

 

There is no absolute best refrigerant

The comparison between natural and fluorinated fluids therefore confirms that the choice cannot be reduced to a contrast between two families of fluids.

Natural and fluorinated refrigerants have different technical, environmental and safety characteristics , which must be evaluated with respect to the specific application.

The most useful principle for the HVAC/R supply chain is therefore to consider the entire system: refrigerant, machine, energy consumption, operating conditions and life cycle.

The progressive decarbonisation of electricity and the growing attention to environmental impacts beyond GWP could however further change this balance in the coming years, making a comprehensive assessment of the sustainability of the refrigeration system increasingly important.

Related Focus

Supermarket refrigeration: often overlooked critical issues including retrofits, leaks, and data management
Retrofits, leaks, refrigerants, and data management are among the often overlooked critica...
Sustainable refrigeration: efficiency, refrigerants and plant management at the heart of the transition
Sustainable refrigeration requires an integrated approach between low-GWP refrigerants, en...
Refrigerants and efficiency: the double transition of refrigeration
HFC reduction and energy efficiency must go hand in hand to reduce the climate impact of r...

FAQ – Domande frequenti

No. In the sample analyzed, the TEWI differences between natural and fluorinated products were often small, because a significant part of the overall impact comes from the electrical consumption of the equipment.

The TEWI, Total Equivalent Warming Impact, is an indicator that takes into account both the direct emissions of the refrigerant and the indirect emissions associated with the energy consumed by the system during its useful life.

Because TEWI doesn't consider all environmental impacts, some fluorinated refrigerants can generate persistent compounds like TFA during degradation, while natural refrigerants do not produce these compounds.