Refrigerants and efficiency: the double transition of refrigeration
HFC reduction and energy efficiency must go hand in hand to reduce the climate impact of refrigeration.
Reducing the use of high-GWP HFCs is one of the main objectives of the ongoing transformation in the refrigeration and air conditioning sector. However, addressing refrigerants alone is not enough to truly reduce the climate impact of systems.
The transition must in fact proceed on two parallel fronts: on the one hand, refrigerants with a lower climate impact , on the other, equipment and systems capable of consuming less energy throughout their entire life cycle.
This is the principle of the so-called "dual transition," which links the HFC phase-down to improved energy efficiency. The benefit is twofold: reducing direct emissions associated with refrigerant leaks and, at the same time, reducing indirect emissions related to the electricity used by the system.
Efficiency starts with reducing cooling requirements
The first step is not necessarily to install a more efficient machine, but to check whether it is possible to reduce the cooling load that the system must satisfy .
In building air conditioning, this can mean working on the building envelope, shading, ventilation, and internal load management. In commercial refrigeration, however, even seemingly simple solutions can impact energy consumption by limiting heat exchange with the environment and reducing the work required of the system.
Only after having contained the demand is it possible to correctly size the equipment and choose the most suitable refrigeration solution.
For HVAC/R designers and operators, the logic of intervention therefore changes: not starting from the power of the machine, but from the real need , avoiding oversizing and inefficient operating conditions.
A low GWP refrigerant does not automatically make a system efficient
The choice of fluid remains fundamental, but must be evaluated together with the overall performance of the machine.
A system with a low GWP refrigerant can have a significant environmental impact if it operates with high electricity consumption. Likewise, a highly efficient appliance can lose some of its climate benefits if it suffers frequent refrigerant leaks.
Sustainability must therefore be assessed by simultaneously considering:
- GWP and quantity of refrigerant ;
- system energy efficiency;
- design quality;
- correct adjustment;
- real operating conditions;
- frequency of losses;
- maintenance throughout the entire useful life.
This approach leads to moving beyond an evaluation focused exclusively on the type of refrigerant and instead considering the overall impact of the refrigeration system .
Maintenance and adjustment can preserve efficiency over time
The performance declared during the design phase is not necessarily maintained throughout the life of the system.
Dirty exchangers, incorrect charges, refrigerant leaks, inadequate adjustments or poorly maintained components can progressively increase energy consumption and reduce refrigeration performance.
For this reason, maintenance and technical assistance become an integral part of the decarbonisation strategy.
Among the most important activities are:
- leak prevention and detection;
- checking the correct refrigerant charge;
- cleaning of exchangers;
- control of operating pressures and temperatures;
- setpoint verification;
- defrost optimization;
- consumption monitoring;
- maintenance of project conditions.
A properly maintained system therefore allows for simultaneously lower direct emissions and lower electricity consumption .
Standards, incentives and skills must accompany technology
The availability of efficient solutions does not automatically guarantee their diffusion.
The main barriers remain the higher initial costs of some technologies, the uneven application of energy standards, and the limited availability of technicians with adequate skills.
To accelerate the transition , minimum energy performance standards, financial instruments, training and the dissemination of technical information become important.
The issue of expertise is particularly relevant because alternative refrigerants can require very different procedures than traditional HFCs. Hydrocarbons, CO₂, and ammonia introduce specific requirements related to flammability, pressure, or toxicity.
The refrigeration transition cannot be addressed by separating fluids, machines, and professionals. Refrigerant, efficiency, maintenance, and training must go hand in hand , especially as global demand for cooling continues to grow.
Reducing HFCs without impacting energy consumption would only address part of the problem. The real challenge will be to build systems capable of providing more cooling using less energy and refrigerants with an increasingly lower climate impact.
Related Focus
FAQ – Domande frequenti
Because a system's climate impact depends on both the refrigerant's direct emissions and the energy consumed during operation. Addressing both aspects allows for greater climate benefits.
No. The GWP describes the refrigerant's climate impact, but not the machine's efficiency. A system can use a low-GWP fluid and still have high consumption if it's poorly designed, adjusted, or maintained.
Through proper maintenance, leak and charge control, exchanger cleaning, setpoint verification, and performance monitoring, maintaining design conditions helps limit consumption and emissions throughout the system's lifespan.
